CACTUS IN THE SNOW (1971)

Title: CACTUS IN THE SNOW

Year of Release: 1971

Director: A. Martin Zweiback

Genre: Drama, Romance

Synopsis: A soldier on leave from Vietnam falls in love with an offbeat young woman, but his return to duty may just change their lives forever.

Within a film history context: There were quite a few movies made in the late 1960s, and early 1970s, which explored Vietnam veterans, and their return to American society. The vast majority were exploitation films, with some occasional forays into more thoughtful territory. One of the first was Russ Meyer's MOTORPSYCHO! (1965). A film with revenge and murder themes, the Vietnam veteran of the piece was a psychologically tormented man capable of anything. The Vietnam veteran protagonist of THE BORN LOSERS (1967), Billy Jack, was a man more morally upright than other variations on the theme. He helped to keep a sense of law and order in a small town, namely protecting the young women from harm. Such was the popularity of this film, directed by actor Tom Laughlin, that it led to four sequels over the course of almost twenty years. 

Nick Millard's ODDO (1967), was different in nature, with a veteran emotionally spent, and finding fault with anyone who crossed him. Another Vietnam veteran with emotional problems played out this time in Bruce Kessler's ANGELS FROM HELL (1968). The veteran on this occasion was an ex-biker returning to build a new biker gang, seeking to take on the police at their own game. Many of these films, and other examples from the 1960s, were action-oriented in nature, with little, if no, time for reflection. The 1970s also had its mix of exploitation and more conventional narratives, the mental fragility of Vietnam veterans the main accelerator of action.

One of the most infamous depictions of a Vietnam veteran was in THE RAVAGER (1970), directed by Charles Nizet. Notorious for its violent content, it was about a veteran returning home to become a killer and rapist, as he experienced in Vietnam. Rated X in 1970, it is notable for its sheer reveling in sex and violence, something later movies also capitalized on. More comic in intent was Brian De Palma's HI, MOM! (1970). Without violence but with more comedy asides, it was the second film with Robert De Niro as a veteran living in an apartment block, and his experiences with the other people there. Irreverent also was CAPTAIN MILKSHAKE (1970), directed by Richard Crawford. The protagonist this time became involved with drugs and counterculture figures, this filling out the narrative. Burt Topper's THE HARD RIDE (1971), featured bikers similar to others in the genre, but this time around, the plot concentrated upon a man promising his Vietnam friend to carry out a deed, and finding this demanding to deliver. 

In complete contrast, one of the most expressive, impressive films about veterans returning home was Richard Compton's WELCOME HOME SOLDIER BOYS (1971). A carefully plotted film that builds to an unexpected, plausible climax, it was one of the best films in this genre. Similarly, MY OLD MAN'S PLACE (1971), directed by Edwin Sherwin, was a more character-driven piece than action-focused in scope. Two veterans join another on a farm, where tensions spill over. Gunther Collins' JUD (1971), was the sensitive account of a young man who had just returned from Vietnam, and the difficulties he faced in assimilating back into society. Different in range and character, SKYJACKED (1972), directed by John Guillermin, sported a veteran as an airplane hijacker. Trading more in suspense than violence, it was one of the most restrained examples of the genre. CACTUS IN THE SNOW was quite unlike any of the afore-mentioned movies about Vietnam veterans, for a number of reasons.

The vast majority of films in this category dealt in detail with the emotional scars that Vietnam veterans faced in moving back to their lives after their tour of duty. THE BORN LOSERS, CAPTAIN MILKSHAKE, WELCOME HOME SOLDIER BOYS, and JUD, were some of the best examples of this. They tended to shy away from very explicit violence, and spectacular set pieces of carnage. WELCOME HOME SOLDIER BOYS was the most overt in this arena, but even this did not linger too long on grisly physical details. MOTORPSYCHO!, THE RAVAGER, and ANGELS FROM HELL were opposite in orientation, with THE RAVAGER the most strident in its violence quotient. In comparison to these, CACTUS IN THE SNOW stood out for its slower pace, peek into the psyche of its protagonist, and his blooming relationship with a young woman. Romance in the above examples tended not to be a feature of the narrative, with women flitting in an out of the story in WELCOME HOME SOLDIER BOYS and JUD. 

There was a definite mood of misogyny which infused THE RAVAGER, and emasculation of male characters, for the lead to have unfettered access to vulnerable females. None of this was in evidence in CACTUS IN THE SNOW, but a hopeful, inspirational tone to the picture. Harley in the movie does not appear to have deep psychological scars, but a need for companionship during his leave. The charting of Harley's love for Cissy is touching to witness, as is her mutual affection for him. It is one of the softest of the films about Vietnam veterans, but that is not to say it does not leave an impression on viewers. The final sequence leaves spectators with a sense of pathos at how events have transpired for the two main characters, without being maudlin. A beautiful look at love, and the role of war in this, CACTUS IN THE SNOW is an edifying motion picture, and a change of pace for Vietnam veteran-themed movies.

Overview: A. Martin Zweiback was an American director with only one movie in his filmography, being CACTUS IN THE SNOW. He was more active as a writer on several pictures such as THE MAD ROOM, GORP, GRACE QUIGLEY, and ME, NATALIE, including CACTUS IN THE SNOW, and on television. As CACTUS IN THE SNOW was his sole foray into feature films, the review will concentrate on Mr Sweiback's contribution to the movie.

With CACTUS IN THE SNOW, A. Martin Zweiback has made a touching, memorable movie that depicts a different view of Vietnam from what was generally shown in cinema at the time. Many movies in this era were of Vietnam veterans grappling with their return to society, culminating in violent climaxes. CACTUS IN THE SNOW, however, is at the opposite end of the spectrum in this sphere. It is the story of a soldier, Harley, on leave from Vietnam, and his blossoming relationship with Cissy, a spirited young woman. The director has succeeded in bringing this bittersweet, screwy love story to life, but this is not to say that it is a saccharine enterprise with little depth. 

In the early parts of the picture, it appears that this is just a story concerned with discussions of sex, initially stamping CACTUS IN THE SNOW as being an exploitation movie. Thankfully, this threadbare discussion gives way to the affecting two-character structure which compels for the remainder of the film. The unraveling of the love story between these two likable protagonists is the strength of CACTUS IN THE SNOW, and witnessing the to and fro in their fractured, but appealing tale, makes this a winner. While the movie is not for those who crave fast and furious in their storytelling, the subtlety of CACTUS IN THE SNOW is in its intricate, quiet foundation, and character-driven nature. A movie which deserves much more acclaim than it has received over the years, CACTUS IN THE SNOW is a revealing slice of life, and a testament to its director.

Acting: Three thespians dominate CACTUS IN THE SNOW with their incisive portrayals. As soldier Harley MacIntosh, on leave from Vietnam, Richard Thomas is in one of his best early acting performances. A likeable actor with a soothing charm, he is convincing as a young man caught up in a predicament for which he is unprepared, but warms to this as time passes. The object of his longing, Cissy, is a great role for Mary Layne. Her ease with both comedy, and drama more than evident, Miss Layne brings forth a pathos, and zaniness, which perfectly complements Richard Thomas, and makes their pairing work. The final acting contribution to be discussed is that by Dennis Fimple as Mr Murray, proprietor of the carousel which Harley and Cissy visit. Only onscreen in a handful of scenes, nevertheless, Mr Fimple makes an impact with his appearance, making one wish that his role was lengthened further in the movie.

Soundtrack: Joe Parnello's music nicely functions in the background in CACTUS IN THE SNOW without being overpowering. It adds to the pensive, thoughtful, lightly humorous atmosphere for which the film strives, and succeeds in its objective.

Mise-en-scene: The dreamy nature of CACTUS IN THE SNOW is deftly personified by its visual sense. David Walsh's photography is soft and lovely to witness, giving the movie a unique look and aura. Location filming is another plus, with the streetscapes, beach scenes, and roads all attractive to the eyes. Interiors such as Cissy's family home are also pleasing, the style of decor surprisingly holding up well, and not dated in appearance for a movie made in the 1970s. The inclusion of the carousel ride which Harley and Cissy frequent is a pivotal set piece of the story, and is indicative of the romantic, delicate orientation of CACTUS IN THE SNOW.

Notable Acting Performances: Richard Thomas, Mary Layne, Dennis Fimple.

Suitability for young viewers: Parental guidance advised. Adult themes.

Overall Grade: B

Link: IMDB Page

ALICE'S RESTAURANT (1969)

Title: ALICE'S RESTAURANT

Year of Release: 1969

Director: Arthur Penn

Genre: Comedy, Drama

Synopsis: The story of musician Arlo Guthrie, who among his activities tries to avoid the draft for Vietnam, sings, roams the countryside, and falls in with the crowd of Alice's restaurant in Massachusetts. 

Within a film history context: During the late 1960s and early 1970s, there were numerous films which were concerned with anti-establishment counterculture characters and scenarios. One of the first was Roger Corman's THE TRIP (1967). After suffering a traumatic divorce from his wife, a television director falls into drugs, and has many way out experiences. Notable for its cast, including Peter Fonda, Dennis Hopper, and Bruce Dern, it was an interesting foray into counterculture themes. THE NUDE RESTAURANT (1967), directed by Andy Warhol, was the confrontational story of a restaurant, its waiters, waitresses and patrons, discussing a little of everything in this underground movie. More entertaining was Eliot Silverstein's THE HAPPENING (1967). Four young people kidnap a wealthy man, and hold him to ransom, but events conspire against their original plans. As with many counterculture movies it had a splendid cast, in this case Anthony Quinn in the lead role, with support from George Maharis, Michael Parks, and Faye Dunaway in an early part. Different in tone was GREETINGS (1968), directed by Brian de Palma. It was an unconventional tale of three men getting up to many adventures in late 1960s New York City, with references to issues fresh at the time such as Vietnam, how to avoid the draft, and computer dating. It led to a sequel in 1970 being HI, MOM!, which was equally irreverent, both films starring Robert De Niro. Also raucous was Barry Shear's WILD IN THE STREETS (1968). A young rock singer becomes president of the United States, which leads to much mayhem, but many colorful, original set pieces. 

SKIDOO (1968), directed by Otto Preminger, was a comedy about the life of a former hit man, and the many outrageous situations in which he, and his family, participate. Alternately dealing with topics such as the counterculture, hippies, free love, and LSD, it was a departure for its director, but not a financial success in its original release. Bob Rafelson's HEAD (1968), was akin in some respects, but in a much more innocent vein. The film charted the exploits of pop group The Monkees, with many musical interludes, and adventures thrown in. On the other hand, PSYCH-OUT (1968), directed by Richard Rush, concerned a young deaf woman looking for her brother in San Francisco, and how through this odyssey she encounters wild characters, with the effects of drugs deftly portrayed in the narrative. Outlandish could be said to describe Hy Averback's I LOVE YOU, ALICE B. TOKLAS (1968). Through a series of events, a straitlaced attorney meets a flower power young woman, and becomes part of the hippie lifestyle, this experience changing his views on love, and life. ALICE'S RESTAURANT had that quirky sensibility which infused many of the above films, but added its own touches to the counterculture movies.

As with most of the films in this category, ALICE'S RESTAURANT had a central male protagonist, expressing his views on life, and tubthumping authority whenever possible. THE TRIP, GREETINGS, WILD IN THE STREETS, and I LOVE YOU, ALICE B. TOKLAS are prime examples of this. These are story worlds where anything can happen, with sometimes outrageous incidents highlighted. This was marked more in the latter three movies, which are all comedic in intention. Where ALICE'S RESTAURANT diverted was that Arlo was a folk singer, whereas in the other movies, their occupations were different. The closest film to ALICE'S RESTAURANT in terms of this was WILD IN THE STREETS, with its rock star becoming president, but that film was geared towards satire, and overt comedy. ALICE'S RESTAURANT, by no means a drama, had comic interludes, but did not send up its characters mercilessly, as exemplified by WILD IN THE STREETS. 

There was a quietness, and a subtlety in ALICE'S RESTAURANT, with the lead going through the mill of draft dodging, and hot and heavy relationships with various women. This was contrasted with the single-mindedness of Max in WILD IN THE STREETS, and how he did anything to progress, even if other people were hurt. A free love mentality, though, was present in both WILD IN THE STREETS and ALICE'S RESTAURANT. It was all about the journey for the free-floating Arlo, rather than the rampant sexuality of the egomaniacal Max Frost. This gave ALICE'S RESTAURANT a thoughtful background which was in keeping with the time of its release. Another interpretation of a counterculture character, ALICE'S RESTAURANT is a beguiling account in this respect.

Overview: Arthur Penn was an American film director from 1958 until 1995, helming thirteen motion pictures. His works were predominately dramas, with action, biopics, crime, and thrillers among his output. Mr Penn's first movie, THE LEFT HANDED GUN (1958), followed Billy the Kid as he avenged the killing of his friend by murdering those involved in this crime, but his actions will affect the lives of his close associates. Next came one of Arthur Penn's most notable movies, THE MIRACLE WORKER (1961). The relationship of blind and deaf Helen Keller with her companion, Anne Sullivan, was brought to the screen in a full-blooded biopic, winning Oscars for both Patty Duke as the young Helen, and Anne Bancroft as Anne. Crime drama MICKEY ONE (1965), was about a stand-up comic who finds himself at odds with the Mob, appropriating the identity of another man, and continuing his comic act. In the compelling melodrama THE CHASE (1966), a young man returns to his Texas hometown after escaping from jail, and the effect of his presence is keenly felt on the townspeople. One of Arthur Penn's most celebrated movies came in the form of BONNIE AND CLYDE (1967). Charting the criminal escapades of Bonnie Parker and Clyde Barrow in the 1930s, with its all-out presentation of violence, and courage of its convictions, this biopic made a definite statement at the box office, where it was one of the year's most successful films. The 1970s brought Arthur Penn further interesting pictures.

LITTLE BIG MAN (1970), told the tale of a supercentenarian man who reminisces about his life from childhood, when he was taken in and raised by American Indians, dealings with General Custer, and other events in this western. Crime again made its mark in NIGHT MOVES (1975). When a private investigator is assigned by an actress to find her missing daughter, he uncovers a lot more than first expected in this modern noir drama. One of Arthur Penn's least successful outings was THE MISSOURI BREAKS (1976). A horse thief comes up against a determined rancher, who, with the assistance of another man, seeks to halt the stealing of horses in a very permanent way. Critically derided, with a low box office take in its era, time, though, has been somewhat kinder to this western. Into the 1980s, the underrated FOUR FRIENDS (1981), surveyed the lives of several characters from the tumultuous 1960s until the early 1980s. Despite good notices from critics, it lost money for its studio. TARGET (1985), mined thriller territory, this time, a woman holidaying in Europe parts with her tour group, this arousing the suspicion of her husband and son, who seek to find her. DEAD OF WINTER (1987), was a venture into horror for Mr Penn. An actress tries to help the financial situation of herself and husband by taking on an acting role, but this is just the start of her problems. Athur Penn's last movie was PENN & TENNER GET KILLED (1989). The exploits of a comic duo made up the content of this black comedy, but it was not a fitting final tribute to the director. ALICE'S RESTAURANT was Arthur Penn's seventh film, but not one of his best efforts.

In the case of ALICE'S RESTAURANT, Arthur Penn has made a passable movie with some edifying passages. Taking as its focus a folk singer who tries to avoid being drafted for Vietnam, and his eventual move to friends in Massachusetts, who live in a deconsecrated church, it is an interesting, if flawed picture. Admittedly, there is a certain charm to the proceedings, and the way in which events occur in a random order, but the storytelling, and style of presentation, has not stood the test of time. It may have been relevant at the time of its release for its notions of the counterculture, and beliefs about the Vietnam War, but in retrospect, has not dated well. The to and fro of the narrative does become grating when watching the movie, as one wants something more concrete in terms of an emotional experience, but it rarely happens. Aside from this, the majority of the action actually takes place away from Alice's restaurant, thus skewing the effectiveness of the title. While the title was utilized to capitalize upon the song of the same name, that is the extent of its function. This is not the be all and end all of matters, but does misinform viewers as to the setting of the film. A picture which tries to be irreverent and current but is now mainly of historical interest, ALICE'S RESTAURANT is a chaotic movie from Arthur Penn.

Acting: There are four acting performances which are striking in ALICE'S RESTAURANT. In the lead role, musician Arlo Guthrie has a natural, relaxed presence which works well with the unconventional feel of the movie. As the eponymous Alice, Patricia Quinn adds realism, spunk, and fire to the picture, making her a flesh and blood figure to whom the audience can relate. In contrast, Alice's intriguing husband, Ray, is a dashing turn by James Broderick. With his appealing swagger but also, quiet moments, Mr Broderick is a distinctive personality who adds depth to the proceedings. The last acting of note was by Michael McClanathan as Shelly, Arlo's sensitive friend. In many instances, Mr McClanathan does not have to say a single word for the viewer to comprehend his feelings, and this makes him another unique persona among the others in ALICE'S RESTAURANT.

Soundtrack: ALICE'S RESTAURANT has a pleasing soundtrack, mainly consisting of songs performed diegetically by Arlo Guthrie, but also, with non-diegetic music sprinkled throughout the movie. It is interesting how the opening credits eschew music, instead offering a sound byte of the draft sequence. The closing credits are entirely converse, with an introspective tune played which continues nicely from the end scene of Alice staring into the yonder. This leaves the movie on a solemn but bittersweet note, and is one of the best moments of ALICE'S RESTAURANT.

Mise-en-scene: ALICE'S RESTAURANT has much going for it in terms of offering viewers a convincing visual experience. Michael Nebbia's cinematography is subtle, not emphasizing colour to a great degree, but with an unforced flair which is symptomatic of the picture as a whole. There are quite a few outdoor sequences in the movie, and these all add to the sense of realism which ALICE'S RESTAURANT stives for in its presentation. Production design by Warren Clymer, and John Mortensen's set decoration, create a fantastical world which the characters inhabit, with Alice's restaurant itself being warm and inviting, and the deconsecrated church two key examples of their expertise. 

Notable Acting Performances: Arlo Guthrie, Patricia Quinn, James Broderick, Michael McClanathan.

Suitability for young viewers: No. Male nudity, female nudity, adult themes, drug use.

Overall Grade: C

Link: IMDB Page

Trailer